|
|
Steven Rose's status as radio pundit on Radio 4's the moral maze means his books are packaged to fit the lucrative pop science market. Nothing about the cover of this book would lead an unsuspecting reader to realise that between the shiny front and back page blurb is one of the most complex, ambitious and erudite books on the functioning of the brain yet written. It is a hard read and there are entire sections on microbiology that are impossible to take in without specialist knowledge (I've read a review by a psychiatrist in which he held that there were sections that were beyond him). Yet it is an excellent book and a must read if you have a background understanding of psychology. Rose is particularly scathing about the wilder claims of Darwinian psychology, which he dismisses as being based on two conceptual errors: 'the misunderstanding of the relationship between enabling and causal mechanisms, and the attempt to privilege distal over proximal causes.' This book will aid your engagement skills in no way whatsoever but it is superb and will stretch any reader.
|
One of the cheapest books available, but it isn't worth buying new.
It has a very 'therapeutic' feel (in a strangely prejorative sense) about it and is bulked out with case studies which are not massively illuminating. Most of the author's patient's seem certainly to have troubles but are rarely as chaotic and demanding as the patients/clients most professionals fear working with.
It is precisely this high-chaos, hard-to-reach and limited insight genre of client that workers professionals need guidance on working with - but this is guidance they won't find here.
|
Steven Rose's status as radio pundit on Radio 4's the moral maze means his books are packaged to fit the lucrative pop science market. Nothing about the cover of this book would lead an unsuspecting reader to realise that between the shiny front and back page blurb is one of the most complex, ambitious and erudite books on the functioning of the brain yet written. It is a hard read and there are entire sections on microbiology that are impossible to take in without specialist knowledge (I've read a review by a psychiatrist in which he held that there were sections that were beyond him). Yet it is an excellent book and a must read if you have a background understanding of psychology. Rose is particularly scathing about the wilder claims of Darwinian psychology, which he dismisses as being based on two conceptual errors: 'the misunderstanding of the relationship between enabling and causal mechanisms, and the attempt to privilege distal over proximal causes.' This book will aid your engagement skills in no way whatsoever but it is superb and will stretch any reader.
|
|
|